Review: AD ASTRA Is An Inferior APOCALYPSE NOW In Space

FIRST IMPRESSION

Ad Astra has great visuals and good performances, but the script is simply a re-hash of tropes and themes that have been seen before.
Writing
Directing
Acting
Technical Merit

Ad Astra, co-written and directed by James Gray (The Lost City of Z), is a new star-driven sci-fi epic, a breed of film once thought to be extinct. Visually phenomenal, but lacking in original ideas, this derivative and sometimes tedious meditation on exploration is a disappointingly tedious feast for the eyes.

The movie follows an astronaut who is sent into space to uncover the truth regarding his father who went on a mission thirty years prior which is threatening to impact the future of humanity. If this sounds familiar, it is because it is similar to Apocalypse Now, in fact eerily so. Although Joseph Conrad’s novella Heart of Darkness (the inspiration for Coppola’s film) is not credited, it was obviously an inspiration for Gray while writing his script.

That isn’t to say that the movie is bad — Gray just seems to think that it is more visionary than in actually is. In reality, the film covers already trodden ground, both narratively and thematically. Because of this, every beat in the story feels telegraphed and predictable. There are a few truly exciting scenes (including one riveting action sequence taking place on the moon), but more often than not, the philosophical ramblings of the characters feel like old news.

Much of the movie’s thematic content is delivered via narration from the protagonist. The film has a lot to say about exploration, international politics, and the psychological impacts these have on people, but these big themes aren’t what feels most interesting about this movie. Instead, it is the family drama, in which the protagonist tries to cope with the realization that his father whom he presumed dead may actually still be alive, that is fascinating. Yet the film reaches “to the stars” and leaves the compelling drama underdeveloped on the ground.

ad astra facility
Brad Pitt stars in “Ad Astra”. Credit: Francois Duhamel. Copyright Twentieth Century Fox.

The protagonist, Roy McBride, is an interesting character, but the audience is forced into identifying with his perspective through the narration. Had more natural means been used, this connection would have been stronger and the exposition would have been rendered unnecessary. However, perhaps most frustrating about the movie is the lack of memorable supporting characters. Some of the best moments of Apocalypse Now are those in which the protagonist interacts with zany side characters. That is what is missing from Ad Astra.

Brad Pitt’s performance in the film is great, much more subtle and effective than anything he has done in recent memory. Although his big and flashy turns are more enjoyable, it is nice to see him get work like this in which the details make the difference. The supporting cast is also very good, albeit underused. The best supporting performance comes from Donald Sutherland, although Tommy Lee Jones is likely to get most of the attention.

Of course, the main reason to see this movie is the visual grandeur Gray brings to the screen. This is one of those “see it on the big screen or don’t see it at all” cases that would fall apart even more if watched at home on a smaller screen. The cinematography, visual effects, and production are great, transporting the audience into the futuristic world of the film. Max Richter’s score is also excellent, one of the year’s finest, yet it sadly won’t qualify for major awards on a technicality.

Unfortunately, Ad Astra doesn’t quite reach the heights that it should. It looks great, features good performances, and is entirely watchable, but the writing simply isn’t that special. This will have its fair share of fans, and understandably so, though it is far from a masterpiece.

Ad Astra is now playing in theaters.

TRENDING THIS WEEK

The New Pope (2019): Official Trailer | HBO

Academy Award-winning director Paolo Sorrentino returns with The New Pope, his second original series set in the world of the modern papacy. Written by Sorrenttino with Umberto Contarello and Stefano Bises, the nine-episode original series features Jude Law and John Malkovich. Sharon Stone and Marilyn Manson guest star. #HBO #TheNewPope Subscribe to HBO on YouTube:…

The Shop: Uninterrupted | Controlling Your Narrative in the Media (Episode 8 Clip) | HBO

In this all-new edition, LeBron James and Maverick Carter are joined by four-time Grammy winner Will Smith, six-time MLB All-Star pitcher CC Sabathia, stand-up comedian and actor Martin Lawrence, rapper, songwriter and activist Chance The Rapper and marketing executive Paul Rivera. Stream The Shop now on HBO. #HBO #TheShopHBO Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: https://goo.gl/wtFYd7…

The Marvelous Mrs Maisel | Season 3 In 3 Minutes | Prime Video

WARNING: Spoilers ahead! Everything you need to know about Season 3 as told by the cast of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. » Watch the new season of The Marvelous Mrs.Maisel now exclusively with your Prime Membership: http://bit.ly/TheMarvelousMrsMaiselS3PrimeVideo » SUBSCRIBE: http://bit.ly/PrimeVideoSubscribe About The Marvelous Mrs.Maisel: In 1958 New York, Midge Maisel's life is on track- husband,…

Avenue 5 (2019): Official Teaser | HBO

The vacation you never knew you needed. From Veep creator Armando Iannucci, Avenue 5 launches this January on HBO. #HBO #Avenue5 #Avenue5HBO Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: https://goo.gl/wtFYd7 Don’t have HBO? Order Now: https://itsh.bo/GetHBONow Get More HBO: Get HBO GO: https://play.hbogo.com Like on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/HBO Follow on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HBO Like on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hbo Official Site:…

The Shop: Uninterrupted | Will Smith & Martin Lawrence on Bad Boys (Episode 8 Clip) | HBO

In this all-new edition, LeBron James and Maverick Carter are joined by four-time Grammy winner Will Smith, six-time MLB All-Star pitcher CC Sabathia, stand-up comedian and actor Martin Lawrence, rapper, songwriter and activist Chance The Rapper and marketing executive Paul Rivera. Stream The Shop now on HBO. #HBO #TheShopHBO Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: https://goo.gl/wtFYd7…

The Shop: Uninterrupted | Will Smith Shares Why Willow Smith Shaved her Head (Clip) | HBO

In this all-new edition, LeBron James and Maverick Carter are joined by four-time Grammy winner Will Smith, six-time MLB All-Star pitcher CC Sabathia, stand-up comedian and actor Martin Lawrence, rapper, songwriter and activist Chance The Rapper and marketing executive Paul Rivera. #HBO #TheShopHBO Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: https://goo.gl/wtFYd7 In collaboration with LeBron James and…

Curb Your Enthusiasm: Season 10 | Official Trailer | HBO

Larry David stars as... Larry David, living the good life out in Los Angeles and stumbling through one faux-pas after another. Curb Your Enthusiasm returns for its tenth season Sunday, January 19 at 10:30PM. #HBO #CurbYourEnthusiasm Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: https://goo.gl/wtFYd7 Don’t have HBO? Order Now: https://itsh.bo/GetHBONow Get More HBO: Get HBO GO: https://play.hbogo.com…

The Shop: Uninterrupted | Ft. Will Smith, Chance the Rapper, Martin Lawrence and More Promo | HBO

An all-new episode of The Shop: Uninterrupted airs tomorrow at 10PM on HBO. In this all-new edition, LeBron James and Maverick Carter are joined by four-time Grammy winner Will Smith, six-time MLB All-Star pitcher CC Sabathia, stand-up comedian and actor Martin Lawrence, rapper, songwriter and activist Chance The Rapper and marketing executive Paul Rivera. #HBO…
Avatar
Sean Boelman
Sean is a film student, aspiring filmmaker, and life-long cinephile. For as long as he can remember, he has always loved film, but he credits the film Pan's Labyrinth as having started his love of film as art. Sean enjoys watching many types of films, although some personal favorite genres include dramatic comedies, romantic comedies, heist films, and art horror.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here