Review: ADAM Is An Ill-Informed Attempt To Approach LGBT Issues

FIRST IMPRESSION

Ultimately doing more harm than good, Adam does represent a step forward in diversity both on and off the screen, but suffers from an ill-informed premise.
Writing
Directing
Acting
Technical Merit

Adam, directed by Rhys Ernst and written by Ariel Schrag from her novel of the same name, is a new coming-of-age film that has been the subject of controversy due to its questionable treatment of LGBTQ issues. Ultimately, despite the movie’s seemingly good intentions, it comes off as a woefully misinformed explanation of trans issues from a cisgender perspective.

This film’s issues start with its premise and keep going from there. The movie is about a boy in high school, the eponymous protagonist, who spends a summer with his sister in New York City, where he falls in love with a lesbian woman and pretends to be a trans man in order to start a relationship with her. There are so many things wrong with this premise that you can’t help but wonder why anyone thought it was a good idea in the first place.

The most obvious level of scumminess is that the protagonist is totally disrespecting the LGBTQ community by pretending to be someone he is not. Lying about anything is bad, but lying about something like that is just unethical. Trans people have faced discrimination and oppression for ages so that a high school kid can use it to sleep with a lesbian woman to whom he is attracted? That just isn’t how things work.

Why are we as the audience supposed to like or sympathize with a character who is doing something so horrible? If you have any sense of basic human decency, it is hard to not dislike (or even hate) the protagonist because of what he has done. Yes, the second and third acts are about the character coming to terms with the fact that what he is doing is wrong, but he should have known all along that he was acting unethically. By the end of the film, any consequences he faces would never be enough.

adam couple

However, perhaps more damning is the fact that the movie entirely delegitimize the identities of the LGBTQ community. Since the character pretends to be a trans man to sleep with a lesbian woman, the film is therefore implying that trans men aren’t really men. In what world does a movie that is trying to support LGBTQ rights have this underlying message? It almost feels as if this film is trying to sanitize the real-life issues at its core in a way that is more “palatable” for conservative cis audiences without the realization that those audiences wouldn’t be watching this movie anyway.

The actors all try to give compelling performances, but unfortunately, you will be so distracted by how horribly the characters are written to be able to pay too much attention to the merits of the cast. What can be praised, though, is that director Ernst cast a diverse group of actors, in terms of race, gender identity, and sexual orientation.

On a technical level, the movie was mostly fine, if somewhat unimpressive. The film is set in the mid-2000’s, yet apart from a few quirks in the production design here and there (a movie poster in the background or a character pulling a flip phone from out of his pocket, it looks and feels like it could have been set in any time. Maybe if the movie had been more clearly periodized as being set more than a decade ago, some of its political incorrectness could have been forgiven.

Although Adam has noble intentions and is a step forward for LGBTQ representation both in front of and behind the camera, it simply doesn’t work. This feels like a movie made to be an introduction to trans issues for a transphobic cisgender audience that probably won’t even see it.

Adam opens in theaters on August 14.

TRENDING THIS WEEK

The World Is Yours By Right | The Walking Dead Facts and Easter Eggs Eps. 911-912

We dive into King Ezekiel's desire to watch movies and more in this collection of facts and Easter eggs from The Walking Dead. You can watch all of Season 9 at http://amc.tv/twd-s9yt #WalkingDead #TheWalkingDead Watch The Walking Dead videos: https://goo.gl/P1AXdM Subscribe to the AMC YouTube Channel : https://goo.gl/Tu5rSx Fear the Walking Dead: https://goo.gl/CMLr9K Sign Up…

A Black Lady Sketch Show: Meet the Character with Robin Thede & Gabrielle Dennis Featurette | HBO

“I wanna see more of Elisa.” A Black Lady Sketch Show is a narrative series set in a limitless magical reality full of dynamic, hilarious characters and celebrity guests. The show presents sketches performed by a core cast of black women, including Robin Thede, Ashley Nicole Black, Quinta Brunson, and Gabrielle Dennis. Catch it Fridays…

A Black Lady Sketch Show | Gang Orientation (Full Sketch) | HBO

Not your typical job orientation... A Black Lady Sketch Show is a narrative series set in a limitless magical reality full of dynamic, hilarious characters and celebrity guests. The show presents sketches performed by a core cast of black women, including Robin Thede, Ashley Nicole Black, Quinta Brunson, and Gabrielle Dennis. Catch it Fridays at…

Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel: Center Stage ft. Justin Tucker (Clip 2) | HBO

The time between the snap, the hold and the kick is the most stressful 1.3 seconds in sports, and no one in the NFL handles the pressure better than Justin Tucker, the most accurate kicker in the league. The secret to Tucker’s success isn’t his leg, but his voice: when he isn’t playing football, Tucker…

Mysteries Decoded | The Montauk Project Promo | The CW

Mysteries Decoded is new Tuesdays at 9/8c on The CW. Stream FREE next day only on CW Seed! SUBSCRIBE: http://go.cwtv.com/YTSubscribe About The CW: Official YouTube Channel for The CW Network featuring the hit series Riverdale, as well as Black Lightning, The Flash, Arrow, Supergirl, DC’s Legends of Tomorrow, Supernatural, Jane The Virgin, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, The…

Succession: Greg’s Principles (Season 2 Episode 2 Clip) | HBO

New episodes of Succession S2 air Sundays at 9PM on HBO. #HBO #SuccessionHBO Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: https://goo.gl/wtFYd7 Succession tracks the lives of the Roy family as they contemplate their future once their aging father (Brian Cox) begins to step back from the media and entertainment conglomerate they control. Succession is available to stream…

Goliath Season 3 – Official Trailer | Prime Video

Official Trailer of Goliath Season 3 » Goliath returns 10/4. Watch the current season with Prime: http://bit.ly/GoliathPrimeVideo » SUBSCRIBE: http://bit.ly/PrimeVideoSubscribe About Goliath: Once a powerful lawyer, Billy McBride is now burned out and washed up, spending more time in a bar than a courtroom. However, when the legal system is rigged for the rich and…
Avatar
Sean Boelman
Sean is a film student, aspiring filmmaker, and life-long cinephile. For as long as he can remember, he has always loved film, but he credits the film Pan's Labyrinth as having started his love of film as art. Sean enjoys watching many types of films, although some personal favorite genres include dramatic comedies, romantic comedies, heist films, and art horror.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here