Review: AMERICAN HERETICS: THE POLITICS OF THE GOSPEL Is Politically-Charged In All The Right Ways


Unabashedly and thought-provokingly political, American Heretics: The Politics of the Gospel is a well-made documentary with a surprising story.
Entertainment Value
Technical Merit

American Heretics: The Politics of the Gospel, directed by Jeanine Isabel Butler, is yet another new documentary about the changing role of religion in American society. However, as the title would suggest, the film and its subjects are more concerned with politics than they are with anything else, and the result is a mostly entertaining documentary.

This movie follows a group of Christian ministers and congregations who take a stand against the religion’s fundamentalist status quo to promote a form of the religion with more diversity and inclusivity. The catch? These ministers are working in Oklahoma, in the center of the Bible Belt, where the pushback is sure to be the most severe.

As a result, there is plenty of conflict to be shown in the film, and it is surprisingly cinematic. We get to see both external conflict with fundamentalists who are trying to fight back against the subjects (including a riveting case study involving a female minister who is trying to lead prayer at a state Senate meeting) and the internal conflict within the congregations as they try to decide between the Christianity with which they grew up and the Christianity which they now know.

The filmmakers also do an excellent job of making this movie feel not only relevant to modern politics, but also strikingly urgent. Topics addressed by the film range from gender equality to the immigration crisis. Particularly in relation to the latter topic, this documentary feels important because it explores the ethical implications of both sides of the argument in a way that is earnest and thought-provoking.

american heretics walke

In terms of pacing, the movie is mostly very solid. Butler has cut the movie together in a way that the different stories blend together seamlessly. Though it will (accurately) seem like this film has bitten off a whole lot to chew, it manages to balance all of its themes and subjects effectively and with enough depth to make the end result feel substantial.

The main subject, Dr. Reverend Robin Meyers, is presented in a way that is quite interesting and sympathetic way. Even if you don’t agree with all of his political beliefs, it will be hard not to admire what he is trying to do in order to make the world a better place. Other interviewees and subjects, such as Reverend Lori Walke and Reverend Bishop Carlton Pearson, are also compelling, even if they aren’t developed with as much complexity.

On a technical level, the film was also quite good. The story is told mostly through interviews and fly-on-the-wall footage with a bit of archive material thrown in when necessary. Butler opts for a more straightforward and simplistic style, which benefits the movie in the long run, as it allows the story and subjects to speak for themselves.

Although American Heretics: The Politics of the Gospel doesn’t reinvent the wheel of political/religious documentaries, it is still compelling and meaningful. This film is very much designed to be impactful in this day and age, so definitely check it out if you get the chance.

American Heretics: The Politics of the Gospel is now in theaters.


‘Deal with the Devil’ Ep. 8 Preview | Power Season 6 | STARZ

The Feds turn the heat up on Tommy and bend the rules to scare LaKeisha into cooperating. Ghost discontinues a relationship with an ally. Tasha confronts a snitch, which hits a little too close to home. #Power #STARZ Subscribe to the STARZ YouTube Channel for more Power: Get your free trial of the STARZ…

Mental Health PSA: #RealTalk • Hulu x Film2Future

For World Mental Health Day, Hulu, Film2Future, and The Jed Foundation partnered to challenge the next generation of storytellers to create video spots that encourage people to talk about mental health, connect, share stories, and explore things we can do to help ourselves and others. To find more resources, visit SUBSCRIBE TO HULU’S YOUTUBE…

Batwoman | Exclusive Look | Season Trailer | The CW

Stream new episodes of Batwoman Mondays, free only on The CW App: SUBSCRIBE: About BATWOMAN: Kate Kane (Ruby Rose) soars through the shadowed streets of Gotham as Batwoman. But don’t call her a hero yet. In a city desperate for a savior, she must first overcome her own demons before embracing the call…

‘Nothing Was Solved’ Ep. 5 Clip | Murder In The Bayou Finale | SHOWTIME Documentary Series

Over a decade has passed since the Jeff Davis 8 murders and the families of the victims are still searching for answers. Ethan Brown looks further into what exactly the victims may have known and what has stopped these cases from being solved. His search leads him to a shuttered motel called the Boudreaux Inn,…

(SPOILERS) Inside The Walking Dead Season 10: Alpha and Beta’s Bond

Samantha Morton, Ryan Hurst and the Executive Producers break down Alpha and Beta’s past and why their relationship is so unique. Watch more from The Walking Dead: Subscribe to The Walking Dead on YouTube: #WalkingDead #TheWalkingDead THE WALKING DEAD: Like The Walking Dead on Facebook: Follow The Walking Dead on Twitter:…

Legacies | Far Beyond | Season Trailer | The CW

Stream new episodes of Legacies Fridays, free only on The CW App: SUBSCRIBE: About LEGACIES: The show centers around Hope Mikaelson, the vampire-witch-werewolf hybrid daughter of Hayley Marshall-Kenner and Klaus Mikaelson, and her time at a school for the supernatural called The Salvatore School for the Young and Gifted. Connect with LEGACIES online:…

INTERVIEW: Erica Rice And Getting Tacky Just Right For Between Two Ferns: The Movie

Now on Netflix is Between Two Ferns: The Movie, starring Galifianakis and costume designer Erica Rice has plenty to say about what it takes to make the oddball style of all these characters look right.

Pose | Season 2 Ep. 4: Recap Realness | FX

Remembering Candy. Season 2 on FXNOW. #RecapRealness #PoseFX Subscribe now for more Pose clips: Season 2 of Pose flashes forward in time to 1990. On the heels of the ballroom community establishing itself in pop culture and going mainstream, the House of Evangelista is forced to reevaluate their goals. Meanwhile, the AIDS crisis worsens…
Sean Boelman
Sean is a film student, aspiring filmmaker, and life-long cinephile. For as long as he can remember, he has always loved film, but he credits the film Pan's Labyrinth as having started his love of film as art. Sean enjoys watching many types of films, although some personal favorite genres include dramatic comedies, romantic comedies, heist films, and art horror.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here