Review: LUCY IN THE SKY Has Its Head Too Far In The Clouds


Lucy in the Sky is ambitious, but director Noah Hawley can't seem to figure out what to do with his vision and the phenomenal ensemble he has assembled.
Technical Merit

Lucy in the Sky, the directorial debut of Noah Hawley (the creator of FX’s Legion and Fargo) is a star-studded and ambitious new spacefaring drama. However, despite the sheer abundance of potential this film had, this ends up being one of the year’s biggest disasters due to the fact that Hawley simply doesn’t seem to know what he is doing.

Inspired by true events, the movie follows an astronaut who begins to lose touch with reality after returning from space and feeling enlightened by her experiences. The true story upon which this film is loosely based is actually pretty insane, and yet the approach that Hawley and writers Elliot DiGuiseppi and Brian C. Brown takes manages to turn it into little more than an average melodrama.

There is some interesting subtext in the movie about obsession and its similarities to addiction, but these are sadly buried by the film’s underwhelming attempts to be profound. More often than not, it seems as if the filmmakers were so caught up in trying to be smart and insightful that their work loses almost all of the potential impact that it potentially had.

One of the main problems with the movie is that there is not a character with whom the audience can easily identify. The protagonist, Lucy, isn’t a particularly likable character. Although some viewers may find her quest to find her place in the greater scheme of things to be compelling, many will be put off by her relentlessly selfish actions.

lucy in the sky training
Zazie Beetz and Natalie Portman in the film LUCY IN THE SKY. Photo by Hilary B. Gayle. © 2019 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation All Rights Reserved.

Even though the cast assembled for the film consists of some of the most talented actors working today, their performances never reach their full potential because the material limits them. Natalie Portman gives a solid turn in the title role, and while she never reaches the level of her best work, she is the main reason why the movie is even remotely watchable. The supporting cast includes names such as Jon Hamm, Dan Stevens, Zazie Beetz, Ellen Burstyn, Jeffery Donovan, and Nick Offerman, although they each only get one or two memorable scenes.

That said, perhaps the most frustrating thing about this film is that Hawley tries to experiment with his style to a distracting extent. The aspect ratio of the movie is constantly changing, and it would be hard not to notice. Sometimes the aspect ratios will be comically bad, such as a few instances in which the shot is ridiculously thin, or one side of the screen is left entirely black. To add insult to injury, these decisions are often entirely unwarranted.

Many other choices made by Hawley are questionable. The production design in many sequences is actually quite good, but other scenes utilize excessive green screen or CGI effects and end up being extremely distracting. The soundtrack is also frequently poorly-fit to the film, and even though the score is beautiful on its own, the way in which it is aligned with the visuals doesn’t exactly work.

Likely one of the most disappointing movies of 2019, Lucy in the Sky is a total mess. Even though the script is decent and the ensemble is gifted, Hawley just didn’t have what it takes to bring his vision to life.

Lucy in the Sky is now playing in theaters.


Breeders | Inside Look Season 1: The Car Stunt | FX

Violent. Sudden. What goes into a car stunt? More than you think. Get an INSIDE LOOK at the memorable accident from Breeders with director Ben Palmer. Subscribe now for more Breeders clips: FX’s Breeders is an uncompromising comedy that explores the lives of Paul (Martin Freeman) and Ally (Daisy Haggard) as they juggle full-time…

Better Things | Season 4 Ep. 6: Wedding Song Highlight | FX

We're not crying, you're crying. Subscribe now for more Better Things clips: Better Things is the story of Sam Fox, a single mother and working actor with no filter, raising her three daughters in Los Angeles. She also looks after her mother, an English expat who lives across the street. Whether she's earning a…

Outlander | Ep. 8 Preview | Season 5

The Frasers must come to terms with all that has changed in the aftermath of the Battle of Alamance Creek. An unexpected visitor arrives at the Ridge. Watch new episodes of Outlander Sundays only on STARZ. #Outlander #STARZ Watch Outlander now on the STARZ App: Subscribe now for more Outlander content: Like Outlander…

Short Cuts: Moulin Rouge | Making the Cut

Welcome to Short Cuts! Join Heidi Klum and Tim Gunn on their behind-the-scenes adventures during their travels filming ‘Making the Cut.’ Official Making the Cut Pages: Official Show Instagram: Official Show Twitter: Official Show Hashtag: #makingthecut Don’t miss new Making the Cut episodes every Friday on Amazon Prime Video. About Prime Video: Want…

Star Trek: Picard – You Have To Use Your Imagination (Ep. 10, “Et In Arcadia Ego, Part 2”)

Synthetic technology finds new and interesting ways to test Captain Rios. Stream full episodes of Star Trek: Picard exclusively in the U.S. on CBS All Access. Stream full episodes of "Star Trek: Picard," exclusively in the U.S. on CBS All Access. Subscribe To "CBS All Access" Channel HERE: For more content from "Star Trek:…

Fauda: Season 3 | Official Trailer | Netflix

"Fauda" (Arabic for 'Chaos') tells the story of an undercover unit in the Israeli Defense Forces, Focusing on Doron Kavillio (Lior Raz). In season 3, Doron is deep undercover in the West Bank, posing as an Israeli Arab boxing instructor in a sports club belonging to a low-level Hamas member. Following numerous, deadly clashes with…

The Innocence Files | Official Trailer | Netflix

Through the lens of The Evidence, The Witness and The Prosecution, The Innocence Files shines a powerful light on the untold personal stories behind eight cases of wrongful conviction that the nonprofit organization the Innocence Project and organizations within the Innocence Network have uncovered and worked tirelessly to overturn. The Innocence Files is executive produced…

Defining Moments with OZY: Dominique Jackson’s Story • A Hulu Original

Pose star and trailblazer Dominique Jackson reveals her inspiring path to success in Defining Moments with OZY, now streaming on Hulu. ABOUT DEFINING MOMENTS No one starts out on top, even if it seems like they did. No matter how high they’ve climbed, the most successful people have all struggled on their journey to greatness.…
Sean Boelman
Sean is a film student, aspiring filmmaker, and life-long cinephile. For as long as he can remember, he has always loved film, but he credits the film Pan's Labyrinth as having started his love of film as art. Sean enjoys watching many types of films, although some personal favorite genres include dramatic comedies, romantic comedies, heist films, and art horror.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here