Review: STRANGE BUT TRUE Doesn’t Stick The Landing But Is Still Mostly Compelling


Although the script has a fair amount of flaws, Strange But True is nonetheless an interesting and compelling melodrama/mystery with good performances.
Technical Merit

Strange But True, directed by Rowan Athale, is a new mystery-drama film with plenty of shocking twists. Thanks to some impressive turns from the star-studded ensemble, this film is able to overcome a sometimes ridiculous script to be an enjoyable watch.

This film is about a family whose life is turned upside down when the former girlfriend of a long dead family member visits them, claiming to be pregnant by the deceased. Although this story seems like something that would come out of a soap opera, it is, for the most part, rooted in honest emotion. Some of the twists, particularly those that come towards the end of the film, are rather ludicrous.

Because the film loses touch with reality towards the end, the film ultimately becomes anticlimactic. When the big reveal is made as to what actually proceeded in the story, it is unsatisfying because the ambiguity which the film was working so hard to build for much of the runtime is ruined. In this regard, the film would have benefitted from having a lot more subtlety.

The character development also could have used some work. The main issue with the characters in this film is simply that the ensemble is too big, Since there are so many characters involved in the story, it is difficult to have them all fully developed and explored. Eventually, all of the subplots tie together into the main story, but for a majority of the film, some of the characters feel like throwaways.

strange but true qualley

That said, the emotional core of the film is surprisingly good. The protagonist, played by Nick Robinson, is a very interesting character with whom it is easy to sympathize. His emotional arc, along with this mother’s, about coming to terms with their grief, is the most compelling part of the film, and is dominant for much of the first hour. After that point, the mystery becomes the driving force of the film, and while this part is still entertaining, it isn’t quite as effective.

The cast does an excellent job in the film. Robinson gives a subtle turn in the leading role, playing on some of the strengths he has shown in his other performances. The amazing supporting cast that surrounds him includes Margaret Qualley, Amy Ryan, Greg Kinnear, Brian Cox, and Blythe Danner, though some of their talents feel wasted on miniscule roles. Danner and Kinnear have particularly small roles that did not fully utilize them.

On a technical level, the film is fine, if a little inconsistent. The most distracting part of the film is the sound quality, which was sometimes not up to par. That said, the overall look and style of the film is solid, as it gives the film a surreal and dreamlike air that highlights the ambiguity in the earlier portion.

Strange But True could have used a bit of refinement in the final act, but for the most part, it offers a compelling and twisty mystery. The cast alone makes this film worth a watch.

Strange But True is now in theaters and on VOD.


The Weekly | Season 1 Ep. 25: The Endorsement Preview | FX

For more than a century, The New York Times editorial board has endorsed a presidential candidate every four years. And now, for the first time, their decision-making process will be filmed & revealed to the public in this exclusive episode of The Weekly. Subscribe now for more The Weekly clips: The Weekly is a…

What is the Fate of Rosita’s Love Life? | The Walking Dead

Follow Rosita since she first appeared in The Walking Dead, and the relationships she's had along the way. Watch more from The Walking Dead: Subscribe to The Walking Dead on YouTube: #TheWalkingDead #RositaAndEugene #WalkingDeadSeason10 THE WALKING DEAD: Like The Walking Dead on Facebook: Follow The Walking Dead on Twitter: Visit The…

Troop Zero: Selling Cookies | Prime Video

The ABCs of selling: A - Always B - Be C - Cookies » Watch Troop Zero now exclusively with your Prime membership: » SUBSCRIBE: About Troop Zero: In rural 1977 Georgia, a misfit girl dreams of life in outer space. When a national competition offers her a chance at her dream, to…

The Stranger | Official Trailer | Netflix

We all have secrets. Based on the novel by Harlan Coben, The Stranger forces us to confront a question we all fear - how well do we really know the people closest to us? Starring Richard Armitage, Jennifer Saunders, Siobhan Finneran and Hannah John-Kamen, The Stranger arrives January 30. The Stranger, Only on Netflix:…

The Sweet Sounds of Susie | Presented by Curb Your Enthusiasm | HBO

Relive Susie Greene’s greatest moments with this sweet compilation: Curb Your Enthusiasm returns for its tenth season Sunday at 10:30PM on HBO. #CurbYourEnthusiasm #HBO Subscribe to HBO on YouTube: Don’t have HBO? Order Now: Get More HBO: Get HBO GO: Like on Facebook: Follow on Twitter: Like on Instagram:…

Transporting and Transforming: Costume Designer Ruth E. Carter on DOLEMITE IS MY NAME | Netflix

Eddie Murphy portrays real-life legend Rudy Ray Moore, a comedy and rap pioneer who proved naysayers wrong when his hilarious, obscene, kung-fu fighting alter ego, Dolemite, became a 1970s Blaxploitation phenomenon. From director Craig Brewer; writers Scott Alexander and Larry Karaszewski; and the producing team John Davis, John Fox and Murphy. Oscar-winning Costume Designer Ruth…

Outlander | Season 5: An Inside Look | STARZ

Get an inside look at what’s to come in Season 5 from the cast and crew. Outlander returns February 16 only on STARZ. #Outlander #STARZ Watch Outlander now on the STARZ App: Subscribe now for more Outlander content: Like Outlander on Facebook: Follow Outlander on Twitter: Follow Outlander on Instagram: Outlander…

Night on Earth | Official Trailer | Netflix

When the sun goes down, a new world awakes. New technology reveals wonders of the planet in a completely new light. Across the globe we discover a hidden side to the world's greatest landscapes and animals. Night on Earth, only on Netflix. January 29th. Watch Night on Earth, only on Netflix: SUBSCRIBE: About…
Sean Boelman
Sean is a film student, aspiring filmmaker, and life-long cinephile. For as long as he can remember, he has always loved film, but he credits the film Pan's Labyrinth as having started his love of film as art. Sean enjoys watching many types of films, although some personal favorite genres include dramatic comedies, romantic comedies, heist films, and art horror.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here